Friday, September 19, 2014

ICB essay



How did Capote Cheat Everyone?

            In Cold Blood tells a story about the Clutters murder, focusing on the minds of the criminals as well as the investigators. Salon magazine wrote an article that exposes all of Capote’s lies within and outside of the book. The article said that Capote was willing to bend the truth to support the hero of his story. Indeed, Capote has sold out his readers by changing and discarding details in order to mislead the readers to his own version of the truth. It is the truth where Alvin Dewey and Perry Smith are portrayed to be better people.
            In In Cold Blood, Capote deliberately altered parts of the truth to guide readers to his preferred meaning. By doing this, Capote is not giving the truth and selling out all those who believed in what he said: “immaculately factual.” The article “Truman Capote’s greatest lie” on Salon magazine gave solid evidence to support their claim. In the book, after obtaining some clues, the KBI immediately went to visit Dick’s parents to ask some questions. But according to investigatory documents on this case, the KBI delayed for a few days before visiting Dick’s parents. This little change in details does not affect the book’s veracity significantly, but it is what Capote wants to do. Since most people know about this murder during that time, Capote could not afford to change the plot. However, he could use his talents in writing to make the KBI and Alvin Dewey look good since the KBI showed much more commitment and urgency in the book. In addition Capote’s tone in the book shows that he wanted to make Alvin Dewey the hero, who aspires to bring justice to the Clutters. “The week before Christmas those men turned up in Kansas City - came and went without getting caught - and I never saw Alvin more depressed.” In truth, there was no hero in the Clutters case but as it fits his story, Capote decided to impose one. Alvin Dewey was the one because he led the search, also he helped Capote with essential information. This personal favor might have strengthened Capote’s decision to “bend to truth a bit.”
            Capote did not stop there, he also left out some information that could have been crucial to the book’s interpretation. The truth would be uglier if Capote included everything, which is why he tried to hide these information. A few months after the murder, a family called the Walkers were also killed. This was when Dick and Perry were still under pursuit. By leaving this detail out of the book, Capote is actually killing two birds with one stone. Firstly, many people speculates that Perry and Dick might be the murderers. Capote must have known about this, and he anticipated its potential effects if he includes it. This information might greatly affect Perry’s image in In Cold Blood. In the book, readers might feel some sympathy towards Perry. Clearly, he is trying to give the readers a better image of Perry, whose actions could be influenced by a terrible childhood. If the Walkers murder was included, the readers would have shown much less sympathy to Perry. Capote is said to have developed a good relationship with Perry, and no doubt it affected his writing. Secondly, Capote is doing the KBI and Alvin Dewey a favor. Some people might also blame the KBI for the Walkers murder because if Perry and Dick was caught earlier, the Walkers family might have been alive. This murder will blemish the image of Alvin Dewey, the hero that Capote took a lot of effort to create. As said before, Capote received a lot of help from Alvin and it is reasonable if he writes good things about Alvin.
            Capote altered and left out some of the truth in favor of Perry Smith, Alvin Dewey and Capote’s preferred meaning of the book. Capote sold out his readers because he gave his own version of the truth while promising a factual book. This raises questions about the overall veracity of the non-fiction genre, because other authors of the same genre might have changed their stories to make better ones. Although Capote’s work is incredible, he should be criticized heavily on his untruthfulness.